| 2020-2021-2022 Jim Kuchenbecker Bull Shoals PD | 2004-2005 Montie Sims Dardanelle PD | 1987-1988 Kyn Wilson Clarksville PD |
| 2019-2020 Jackie Davis Cabot PD | 2003-2004 Montie Sims Dardanelle PD | 1986-1987 John Morgan El Dorado PD |
| 2018-2019 Chad Henson Trumann PD | 2002-2003 J.R. Thomas Searcy PD | 1985-1986 Jerry Edwards Harrison PD |
| 2017-2018 Todd Stovall Paragould PD | 2001-2002 Randy Reed Fort Smith PD | 1984-1985 “Sonny” Simpson Little Rock PD |
| 2016-2017 Chad Henson Trumann PD | 2000-2001 Gary Ashcraft Hot Springs PD | 1983-1984 Bob Jones Fayetteville PD |
| 2015-2016 JR Wilson Hope PD | 1999-2000 Larry K. James UCAPD – Conway | 1982-1983 Gary Robertson Fairfield Bay PD |
| 2014-2015 Montie Sims Dardanelle PD | 1998-1999 James Smith DeQueen PD | 1981-1982 Bobby Keen West Memphis PD |
| 2013-2014 Montie Sims Dardanelle PD | 1997-1998 Loy Dewey Clinton PD | 1980-1981 Tommy Goodwin Springdale PD |
| 2012-2013 Percy Wilburn Lake Village | 1996-1997 Wayne S. Cone Harrison PD | 1979-1980 Julius Smith UALR PD– Little Rock |
| 2011-2012 Greg Donaldson Clarksville PD | 1995-1996 Bob Roberson Waldo PD | 1978-1979 Travis Bennett Cave Springs PD |
| 2010-2011 Keith Jackson Greenwood PD | 1994-1995 Paul Rivaldo Barling PD | 1977-1978 David Dunaway Warren PD |
| 2009-2010 Montie Sims Dardanelle PD | 1993-1994 Bob Johnson Arkadelphia PD | 1976-1977 Cleddie Shock Pine Bluff PD |
| 2008-2009 J.R. Thomas Arkansas ATC | 1991-1993 Montie Sims Dardanelle PD | 1975-1976 Jack Cole Rogers PD |
| 2007-2008 Gary Kelley Marion PD | 1990-1991 Richard Thomas Hope PD | 1974-1975 James Hanley Jonesboro PD |
| 2006-2007 Danny Bradley North Little Rock PD | 1989-1990 Richard Thomas Hope PD | 1973-1974 Gray Edwards Crossett PD |
| 2005-2006 Danny Bradley North Little Rock PD | 1988-1989 Frank Neely Jacksonville PD |
